Why Good Girls Season 5 Won’t Happen: NBC Cancels Show

Good Girls Season 5

Good Girls was a beloved TV series that aired on NBC for four seasons. Starring Christina Hendricks, Retta, and Mae Whitman, it followed three suburban mothers who turn to a life of crime to make ends meet. While fans eagerly anticipated a fifth season, it was ultimately announced that the show would not be returning. Here is a closer look at why Good Girls Season 5 won’t happen.

NBC Cancels Good Girls

In the summer of 2021, NBC officially canceled Good Girls, much to the disappointment of fans. While the show had a loyal following and did well on streaming platforms, it struggled to attract viewers on traditional TV. In the 2020-2021 TV season, the show was last in ratings in both total viewers and the 18-49 demographic, which is crucial for advertisers.

Global Success on Netflix

Despite its struggles on NBC, Good Girls found a second life on Netflix, where it was billed as a Netflix Original Series in many countries. Each season would often appear on the streamer’s top 10 lists around the world after it was released. The show’s popularity on Netflix led to hopes for a fifth season to bring the story to a close.

Pay Cuts and Creative Issues

The decision to cancel a show that has gained such popularity globally is always puzzling, especially when the lead actors have agreed to take pay cuts to ensure the show’s closure. The cancellation of ‘Good Girls’ despite its popularity on Netflix has left many wondering about the reasons behind it. One of the reasons given for the cancellation was financial issues.

The production of a show can be expensive, and NBC may have found it difficult to justify the expense of producing the final season. Despite the global success on Netflix, the show did not perform well on NBC, ranking last in both total viewers and the 18 to 49 age demographic. The low ratings may have made it difficult for the network to justify the expense of producing a final season, even with the lead actors’ pay cuts. Another reason given for the cancellation was creative differences.

In any production, creative differences can arise between producers, writers, and actors, and these differences can affect the direction and quality of the show. While it is unclear what creative differences may have arisen between the parties involved in ‘Good Girls,’ it is possible that these differences played a role in the show’s cancellation. However, one of the more intriguing reasons given for the cancellation was a rumored feud between Christina Hendricks and Manny Montana, who played Rio on the show.

Both actors had discussed their frosty working relationship on set. Montana had even said that Hendricks would refuse to speak to him between takes, and the tension between the two was palpable on screen. It is unclear whether this feud played a role in the show’s cancellation, but it is possible that the tension between the two actors may have made it difficult for the show to continue.

Ultimately, the cancellation of ‘Good Girls’ despite its global success on Netflix and the lead actors’ pay cuts is a reminder of the complex factors that go into the decision-making process behind the production of a show. While financial issues and creative differences may have played a role in the show’s cancellation, the rumored feud between two of the lead actors highlights the interpersonal dynamics that can affect the production of a show.

Retta Says ‘One Person Ruined It for All of Cast and Crew’

In a recent interview on Live With Kelly and Ryan, Retta shed some light on why Good Girls Season 5 isn’t happening. She revealed that the cast and crew were very close to getting a fifth season, but one person ruined it for everyone. She didn’t disclose the identity of the person in question, but she did say that it was too late to replace them, as they would have to start filming soon and figure out the story.

No Chance for Revival on Netflix

With the cancellation of Good Girls, fans were left wondering if there was a chance for the show to be revived on Netflix, much like another NBC cult favorite, Manifest. Unfortunately, plans to do so did not work out, though the show’s production company did look into the possibility. This means that Good Girls Season 5 will not happen, and the story will remain unfinished.

Tributes From the Cast

After the news of the show’s cancellation, the cast took to social media to express their love and gratitude for the show and its fans. Mae Whitman, who played Annie, posted an emotional message on Instagram, saying that she was too sad and confused to look at her phone. She thanked her co-stars and fans for their support and said that it was a joy to play Annie.

The End of Good Girls

Good Girls was a unique and entertaining show that brought together a talented cast and crew. Despite its struggles on traditional TV, it found a global audience on Netflix, which only added to fans’ hopes for a fifth season. However, due to a variety of factors, the show will not be returning. While it’s sad to see it go, we can take comfort in the fact that it brought us four great seasons of drama, humor, and heart.

The Reaction of Good Girls’ Stars and Fans

After learning that the show was ending, Whitman led tributes to the show, saying she was going to “cry now.” In an Instagram story, she wrote: “Feel too sad and confused to look at the phone…Love my pals on this cast so much, and love you guys who loved the show. It was such a joy being Annie, and I’m forever grateful to you for supporting us. [O]K me go cry now.” Fans of the show expressed their disappointment and frustration on social media, with many calling for the show to be picked up by another network or platform. Some also started a petition to save the show, which garnered over 60,000 signatures.


Good Girls Season 5 was highly anticipated by fans of the show, but unfortunately, NBC decided not to move forward with the final season. Despite the show’s success on Netflix and cult following, low ratings on NBC played a significant part in the decision to cancel the show.

The rumored feud between Christina Hendricks and Manny Montana may have also contributed to the cancellation. While there were hopes that another network or platform would pick up the show, those plans did not materialize. The show’s stars and fans expressed their disappointment and sadness at the news, but the decision to end the show was ultimately out of their hands.